تحلیل انتقادی خوانش جابری از معرفت عرفانی و جایگاه آن در میراث اسلامی

نوع مقاله : مقاله علمی پژوهشی

نویسندگان

1 دانشیار دانشکده علوم اجتماعی دانشگاه تهران

2 استادیار موسسه علمی‌پژوهشی امام خمینی ره

3 دانشجوی دکتری اندیشه معاصر مسلمین و استاد همکار جامعه المصطفی العالمیه

چکیده

یکی از روشنفکران معاصر جهان عرب، محمد عابدالجابری است که با طرح پروژه عقل عربی در برابر عقل اسلامی، با نگاه اپیستمولوژیک به واکاوی عقل عربی برساخته از فرهنگ جهان اسلام و عناصر تأثیرگذار در آن پرداخته است. این مقاله با روش تحلیلی انتقادی و در چارچوب نظری رئالیسم انتقادی صدرایی و عرفان محی­الدین به نقد خوانش جابری از معرفت عرفانی خواهد پرداخت. دغدغه جابری پیشرفت و توسعه جهان اسلام و علل عقب­ماندگی جهان اسلام در برابر غرب است. وی عقل مستقیل یا عقل کنارنهاده را همان جریان فلسفه هرمسی و مهم­ترین عامل انحطاط عقل عربی اسلامی دانسته است. جابری معرفت عرفانی را معرفتی سوبژکتیو دانسته که آثار عینی و اجتماعی ندارد و دچار انحرافات بسیاری از جمله، ظهوری/ بطونی­ و تأویلی­بودن معارف دین، معطوف به آخرت بودن، ادعای حلول با خداوند در شطحیات و اسقاط تکلیف شده است. بنابراین هرچه در مضامین متون دینی، رایحه معنویت­گرایی و رویکرد اشراقی باشد. از دیدگاه جابری محکوم به هرمس­گرایی بوده و افسانه­ای بیش ­نیست. در نقد دیدگاه جابری باید معرفت عرفانی را به جهت حضوری ­بودن آن، معرفتی عینی و ناشی از کشف و دستیابی به واقع و اتصال به نفس­الامر عالم و برخاسته از واقعیت دانست. به علاوه عرفان اسلامی به اعتراف مستشرقین از جمله ماسینیون و نیکلسون اختصاص به خود اسلام داشته و وارداتی نیست.

کلیدواژه‌ها


عنوان مقاله [English]

Critical analysis of Jabri's understanding of mystical knowledge and its in Islamic heritage position

نویسندگان [English]

  • Hamid Parsania 1
  • Qasim Ebrahimipour 2
  • Seyyed Mohammad Hossein Hosseini 3
1 Associate Professor, Faculty of Social Sciences, Tehran University
2 Assistant Professor at Imam Khomeini Educational and Research Institute, Qom
3 PhD student of contemporary Muslim thought and associate professor of Al-Mustafa Al-Alamiya communit
چکیده [English]

One of the contemporary Arab intellectuals is Muhammad Abed al-Jabari, who, with the project of Arabic intellect against Islamic By planning the project, analyzed the Arab intellect based on the culture of the Islamic world and its influential elements with an epistemological perspective. This article will criticize Jabri's understanding of mystical knowledge with a critical analytical method and in the theoretical framework of Sadrai's critical realism and Mohiuddin's mysticism. Jabri's concern is the progress and development of the Islamic world and the causes of the backwardness of the Islamic world compared to the West. He considered the independent intellect or isolated intellect to be the current of Hermetic philosophy and the most important factor in the decline of Arabic-Islamic intellect. Jabri considered mystical knowledge to be a subjective knowledge that has no objective and social effects and has suffered many deviations, such as the emergence/interpretation of religious teachings, being focused on the hereafter, claiming to be reconciled with God in the affairs of the world, and the abandonment of the task. Therefore, whatever there is a scent of spiritualism and enlightening approach in the themes of religious texts, from Jabri's point of view, it is condemned to Hermeticism and is nothing more than a legend. In criticizing Jabri's point of view, mystical knowledge should be considered to be an objective knowledge resulting from the discovery and achievement of the reality and connection to the self of the Nafs al-Amr of  the world and arising from the reality. In addition, Islamic mysticism, according to the confession of orientalists such as Masignon and Nicholson, belongs to Islam itself and is not imported.One of the contemporary Arab intellectuals is Muhammad Abed al-Jabari, who, with the project of Arabic intellect against Islamic By planning the project, analyzed the Arab intellect based on the culture of the Islamic world and its influential elements with an epistemological perspective. This article will criticize Jabri's understanding of mystical knowledge with a critical analytical method and in the theoretical framework of Sadrai's critical realism and Mohiuddin's mysticism. Jabri's concern is the progress and development of the Islamic world and the causes of the backwardness of the Islamic world compared to the West. He considered the independent intellect or isolated intellect to be the current of Hermetic philosophy and the most important factor in the decline of Arabic-Islamic intellect. Jabri considered mystical knowledge to be a subjective knowledge that has no objective and social effects and has suffered many deviations, such as the emergence/interpretation of religious teachings, being focused on the hereafter, claiming to be reconciled with God in the affairs of the world, and the abandonment of the task. Therefore, whatever there is a scent of spiritualism and enlightening approach in the themes of religious texts, from Jabri's point of view, it is condemned to Hermeticism and is nothing more than a legend. In criticizing Jabri's point of view, mystical knowledge should be considered to be an objective knowledge resulting from the discovery and achievement of the reality and connection to the self of the Nafs al-Amr of  the world and arising from the reality. In addition, Islamic mysticism, according to the confession of orientalists such as Masignon and Nicholson, belongs to Islam itself and is not imported.

کلیدواژه‌ها [English]

  • Abed al-Jabari
  • Arabic intellect
  • mystical knowledge
  • Islamic mysticism
  • independent intellect